
Signs Your Alternator Is Failing (Alternator or Battery?)
Written by Petro Olekhnovych, mobile mechanic in Aylesham, Kent
The battery starts the car. The alternator then takes over, running the electrics and recharging the battery as you drive. When one fails, the other often gets the blame, and plenty of people fit a new battery only to be stranded again a week later.
Signs the alternator is failing
- Battery light on while driving. Despite the name, this light usually points at the charging system rather than the battery itself. See our guide to the battery warning light.
- Dim or flickering headlights and dashboard, especially when the heater fan, wipers and heated screen are all on.
- Odd electrical behaviour: slow electric windows, the radio resetting, warning lights coming and going.
- Whining or grinding that rises with engine speed, often from worn bearings inside the alternator.
- Burning or hot electrical smell, which can mean the alternator is overheating or the belt is slipping on its pulley.
- Battery flat after a long drive. A healthy charging system should top the battery up on a run from Aylesham to Canterbury and back.
- Engine cutting out while driving, once the battery has been drained by the electrics.
Alternator or battery: how to tell
| What happens | More likely |
|---|---|
| Slow cranking on cold mornings, fine once running | Battery |
| Flat after sitting for a few days, fine after a jump and a drive | Battery or a parasitic drain |
| Battery light on while driving | Alternator, wiring or belt |
| Starts after a jump, then flat again after a journey | Alternator |
| Lights dim at idle and brighten when revved | Alternator |
A car that goes flat overnight with a perfectly good alternator may have something drawing power when it is locked. That is a separate fault, covered in car battery drain overnight.
Warning light on? We come to you.
Send a photo of the dashboard and your reg. We will tell you if it looks safe to drive and what it needs.
WhatsApp for a free quote Call 07563 350335 Contact form
Labour £30 to £50 per hour depending on the job. Send your reg number and we will reply with a price before any work starts.
The voltage check
If you own a simple multimeter, you can do a safe check across the battery terminals:
- Engine off, car rested for an hour or more: a healthy, charged battery reads roughly 12.6 volts. Noticeably lower suggests it is discharged or worn.
- Engine running at idle: most cars show roughly 13.5 to 14.7 volts. A reading close to the engine off figure means the alternator is not charging.
- Keep hands, leads and clothing well away from the belt and fan while the engine runs.
Many modern cars have smart charging, which deliberately lowers the voltage at times to save fuel, so a single low reading is not always a fault. Never test an alternator by disconnecting the battery with the engine running. It is an old trick that can damage the electronics on any modern car.
What causes an alternator to fail
- Worn brushes or a failed voltage regulator inside the unit
- Worn bearings, often noisy first
- A slipping or worn auxiliary belt or weak tensioner
- Corroded or loose wiring and earth connections
- Fluid leaks, such as oil or coolant, dripping onto it
Winter is when weak alternators get found out, because lights, heater, wipers and heated screens all run together on short dark trips.
When to stop driving
If the battery light comes on and the lights start dimming, turn off anything you do not need and head somewhere safe. If the steering also goes heavy or the temperature gauge climbs, the belt may have broken, so pull over and switch off. Do not set off on the A2 or M20 at night with a known charging fault, as you can lose lights at speed.
How we can help
We come to you with a code reader and test equipment, check the battery health, the charging voltage at idle and under load, the belt and tensioner and the main wiring connections. That tells you whether the battery, the alternator or something else is to blame before you buy any parts. Supplying and fitting batteries and alternators are not services we confirm on every car, so once we know the fault we will tell you honestly whether it is a job we can do at your home. Labour is £30 to £50 per hour, and we quote first. If it will not start at all, see car won't start.
Send your reg and postcode on WhatsApp 07563 350335 or use our contact page.
Warning light on? We come to you.
Message us on WhatsApp with your reg and postcode, or use our contact form, for a price before any work starts.
WhatsApp for a free quote Call 07563 350335 Contact form
Labour £30 to £50 per hour depending on the job. Send your reg number and we will reply with a price before any work starts.
Frequently asked questions
How do I know if it is my alternator or my battery?
If the car starts after a jump and keeps running but the battery is flat again after a drive, the alternator is suspect. If it runs fine but will not start after sitting overnight, the battery or a drain is more likely. A voltage test with the engine running gives the answer.
Can I drive with a failing alternator?
Only a short distance, and it is risky. Once the battery is drained the engine can cut out, and you may lose lights and power steering assistance. Head straight home or somewhere safe and get it checked.
What voltage should an alternator charge at?
As a general guide, most cars show roughly 13.5 to 14.7 volts at the battery with the engine running. Many modern cars use smart charging that varies the voltage, so readings need interpreting for the specific car.
What does the battery warning light mean?
Despite its name, the battery light usually means the charging system is not working properly. That can be the alternator, its wiring or the auxiliary belt that drives it.